E-Bodies.org Cuda Challenger Forum

Technical Shop => Tools and Equipment => Topic started by: gumby on October 29, 2019, 05:35:01 AM

Title: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: gumby on October 29, 2019, 05:35:01 AM
Buy Blue Point. Made by Snap-On, their second grade? set. Another alternative, is that Snap-On makes a Black Oxidized tool that is much cheaper than the chrome stuff they sell.
I bought a huge socket set of Blue Point off EBay of Metric and standard short sockets for the fraction of the price of Snap-On. Yet made by the same people.
If you don't want chrome, Black Oxide is also a finish for the fraction of the price. You won't have to ID your tools, because no one else has them.
Snap-On dealers won't tell you about them, because they are so much cheaper. No chrome flaking, same quality.
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: Rich G. on October 29, 2019, 05:47:27 AM
I thought I heard the black was a military grade and not guaranteed. I'll ask my snap on guy when he comes in.
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: gumby on October 29, 2019, 06:26:28 AM
It will be interesting what he says? The Snap-On dealer years ago tried to talk me out of them be cause they would be hard to find if you dropped them on a
dirty floor, and that was about it. They don't really advertise them. How could they be different? I wanted them, because I was in a "black period" just having bought a Grand National.
No chrome is a plus for me?

Same as for the Blue Point line. They don't make as much money off them. But they are far superior for home use or light shop use than anything else.
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: dodj on October 29, 2019, 06:31:33 AM
Quote from: Rich G. on October 29, 2019, 05:47:27 AM
I thought I heard the black was a military grade
I hear the term 'military grade' more and more. Anybody know what it really means?
Ford likes to say their truck is made from 'military grade' aluminium. What's that supposed to mean? It can take a few bullet hits?
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: RUNCHARGER on October 29, 2019, 06:54:54 AM
Black is hard to see. For Canadians, Mastercraft wrenches are good quality for the price.
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: Chryco Psycho on October 29, 2019, 07:48:17 AM
Years ago you bought Snap on or you got junk not so much anymore you can buy decent tools for reasonable prices & at the cost they are disposable .
There are always exceptions .. Flare wrenches for example where cheap tools the jaws will flex open & strip the nut .
At $25 for 15 wrenches you can cut them or bend them to work in difficult spots . Mastercraft is better than Craftsman & decent price especially when they are on sale they almost pay you to take them away !
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: gumby on October 29, 2019, 01:49:57 PM
I remember years ago, a couple of guys were tring to take apart hydraulic fittings.  like 1 1/2 inch? The craftsman back then (1980's) and a Snap-On
The Craftsman would bow its jaws out? The Snap-On held tight. That was back then when Craftsman was "good stuff"

One could not beat Snap-On. The Craftsman bent, but didn't break? To it's credit. The Snap-On didn't even bend? No one is likely to encounter that in a home garage.
That's why I reccomennded Blue Point or the black oxide tools. No one will ever really need the full Snap-On tools for every day use at home.

Yeah, I get all of the other chinese crap garbage that you all are recommending. Holy SCHNIEKIE? just buy something decent - not full blown?
Not professional everyday? The 2nd tier at a cost savings?
Giving you the opportunity to buy some thing decent at a decent price for home use. Chineese crap will end up hurting you? I'm just pointing out
alternatives from cheap chineese crap. Do what you want to do. You will anyway! lol.  :banana:

Blue Point is good stuff. Last I knew, it wasn't china crap?
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: 7E-Bodies on October 29, 2019, 01:51:11 PM
After making payments to snap-off through much of the 80's, I'm surprised they don't own my first born son. I now have 3 ratchets, and a slide hammer attachment that are useless. When I try to get them to a truck, I get the cold shoulder over the phone...sometimes downright rude. I don't even want to know how much I spent with them through the years.
As a self dare, I bought a 3/8 ratchet set in Harbor Freight for under $20. I just knew they'd not hold up. Wrong. It's now my favorite ratchet. I buy American as much as possible, but I simply refuse to deal with arrogance or rudeness. JMO  :alan2cents:
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: JS29 on October 29, 2019, 02:03:55 PM
Some snap-on dealers are like that! You cant beat the flank drive wrenches. Blue point tools are good, I like my gear drive wrenches design from blue point better than the snap-on design. @7E-Bodies (https://forum.e-bodies.org/mlist/7e-bodies_436) If you send me your broken snap-on tools I WILL get them warrantied for you.   :bigthumb:
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: kawahonda on October 29, 2019, 02:05:18 PM
Everytime you want to buy a tool, just do your research. Some cheapies are actually pretty good and can last a long time. Others, not so much.

Some stuff at Harbor Freight is actually the same tool as branded ones.

Many people on Youtube have done tool "tests" which really allows you to make an informed decision. For example, the Pittsburgh harbor freight breaker bar actually tested better than many $200 tools.

My torque wrench is from the company that OEMs Snap On and for a fraction of the price (still about $100). I've posted it before, but I absolutely love it.
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: gumby on October 29, 2019, 02:10:24 PM
That's why I brought this thread up. I had really nice MATCO stuff. The chrome started peeling. They said pound sand. Stuff doesn't last forever.
I have a mix of Snapon, Matco and Craftsman. Snap-On tubing wrenches. Snap-on impact. Everything else, is junk. Or doesn't need the level of quality
of Snap-On for light use. Or Blue Point.
That's why I pointed out Blue Point. Not everyone knows Snap-On makes a second tier tool. Far superior to the chinees crap.

Bust your knuckles once, you'll wish you had bought better. That's all.

Just trying to enlighten people to make better choices. That's all.

My Harbor Frieght POS powered drain auger (sink snake) cleared my pipe, but broke off 2-3 foot at the end while I was retracting it. Thank god, the broken piece
stuck out enough for me to pull it out by hand. One use, first time! Is that what you expect out of your cheap chineese stuff? Learned my lesson.
Wait till it breaks when you most need it - and ends in injury or death? Did you get your moneys worth then?

People get what they deserve. I was trying to point out a lower cost solution to the Chinees stuff, for good quality. You do what you want. Just trying to help out.
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: 7E-Bodies on October 29, 2019, 02:25:18 PM
@JS29 (https://forum.e-bodies.org/mlist/js29_195) I appreciate that very much. However, I plan to either make the local driver make good, or I plan to write the company. I wish I had a recording of his attitude when he realized I only needed things warrantied/repaired. "Well, I might be in that area tomorrow and I might not...you just need to find me. I don't do reservations" (paraphrasing, but that was the gist). His tone of voice was seemingly resentful. Bad move on his part as I'm continually trying to "tool up" my shop as I re-enter this e body hobby.
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: BIGSHCLUNK on October 29, 2019, 04:41:32 PM
Here's a little tidbit..... some Snap-on is made in India..... ssshhhhh don't tell
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: kawahonda on October 29, 2019, 05:00:48 PM
And china too....for example the Harbor Freight Daytona jack (best jack for the money...it's a damn beast) is basically the same jack as the Snap-on. I'd bet they are both made in China. One may be "assembled" in the US, but I bet sourced from the same exact place....

Another tidbit: Snap-on doesn't typically manufacture their own stuff. They pick out what they feel are good OEM tools and brand them as their own. Sometimes it's US...sometimes it's india....sometimes it's China.

Nothing wrong with a "Chinese" tool if it's a good tool....much of those expensive brands are Chinese tools...

Just like people think that Craftsman is US...they haven't been for as long as I can remember.

btw, no tool has ever pissed me off as much as my Craftsman torque wrench. Terrible design. I threw it away with massive force to let it know how much I hate it.

It shouldn't bother you the origins of where a tool is made. My point is to do some research. Youtube is killer these days for tool comparisons that are put through some pretty damn good tests.

I have $80 Matco calipers....but I find myself using the $10 plastic harbor freight one more often. It's pretty much the same reading and still on the same battery after 6 years now. It has a crack in the LCD screen because I've dropped and thrown it around so much. But it still keeps ticking. The Matco calipers I've already had to replace the battery twice and it's had far less use!
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: headejm on October 29, 2019, 05:56:41 PM
My Craftsman set from 1976 is still going strong. Used to be super simple to get broken Craftsman tools replaced but not so much anymore. Stanley bought Craftsman in 2017 and now you can buy them almost anywhere. I'm not sure of the current level of quality but I can definitely vouch for the quality back in 1976.  :cheers:
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: jimynick on October 29, 2019, 06:57:16 PM
I started buying Snap-on in 1971 and they were expensive, then. The guarantee was good, but I also bought Herbrand and SK tools as well and still have most of them. THEN came the Professional series from Canadian Tire and if your vision was a wee bit dim, you'd swear they were Snap-on. They look just like them and they fit/work like them, too. AND, you can buy a set on sale, as mentioned, for what you'd pay for one wrench from S-O with a lifetime guarantee that they don't give you any grief about. Craftsman tools were considered just right- to fix your tractor. Sorry to all aficionados.  :cheers:
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: 7E-Bodies on October 29, 2019, 07:11:09 PM
@kawahonda (https://forum.e-bodies.org/mlist/kawahonda_2011) excellent commentary! I couldn't disagree with a single word of it. I took a chance and dragged home a HF 3/8 torque wrench the other day for some non critical stuff. I had the snap-off 1/4" one that's quite nice, but had a small job that was just out of its reach at 12.5' pounds. I'll probably never need it again, but at $11, hey.
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: JH27N0B on October 29, 2019, 09:34:55 PM
Quote from: dodj on October 29, 2019, 06:31:33 AM
Quote from: Rich G. on October 29, 2019, 05:47:27 AM
I thought I heard the black was a military grade
I hear the term 'military grade' more and more. Anybody know what it really means?
Ford likes to say their truck is made from 'military grade' aluminium. What's that supposed to mean? It can take a few bullet hits?
It's a nonsense term that gets used so often everyone assumes it means something but it doesn't.  Similiar to terms like "assault weapon".  As an engineer hearing it irritates a lot.  I've worked on products for military and their contracts cite "mil specs" which are their standards, not "military grade".  If in Ford commercials Dennis O Leary did his tough guy narration boasting about how Ford trucks aluminum body panels meet tough Mil Spec 123-ABC standards, you could be impressed, but when he starts spewing that military grade BS, its a good excuse to buy a Ram instead!
BTW Snap On made Kobalt tools for Lowes at one point, I'm not sure when that stopped but it's been a while.  I did work for a hand tool company for a couple years, and a few former Snap On people worked there.  They do manufacture most of their own tools, but like all the tool companies, they buy other tools and put their name on it. Danaher used to make a lot of tools that were sold under other names like Craftsman, maybe still do, but I've been out of that industry since getting canned toward the end of 2008 when the economy was crashing by the backstabbing company I worked for, and havent kept up with the industry since I left it.
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: Chryco Psycho on October 30, 2019, 05:19:48 AM
Back in the day of limited choices for tools I had craftsman & hated them , the Snap on guy showed me but putting my Craftsman using the box end  on one end of a nylon hex that the Snap on would hold while the Craftsman stripped , no doubt right !! But then he reversed the 2 wrenches & put the Snap on the nylon hex  where the craftsman wrench had stripped the nylon hex & pulled the 2 wrenches together again as he had before & the Snap on held better on the stripped part & the craftsman stripped the other end of the hex .
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: JS29 on October 30, 2019, 11:51:53 AM
My snap-on flank drive wrench's will take a flare nut off and not strip it. I don't even reach for the brake line wrench set anymore.     :alan2cents:
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: JS29 on October 30, 2019, 12:14:11 PM
@7E-Bodies (https://forum.e-bodies.org/mlist/7e-bodies_436) If you don't buy tools on a regular bases, they don't want to know you! O I get people that get tools at a garage sail and want to get a brand new tool from me. so i blow them off. They don't buy any tools from me Quoted from my Snap-on salesman.      :foul:
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: WCC on October 30, 2019, 01:13:49 PM
Been using Snapon for many years for all of my bikes and cars and they have never let me down, while some other brands did. Of course everybody have their own experience but for me they have been worth the investment and if I had to do it all over again I would definitely buy them again any day of the week and twice on Sundays.
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: Rich G. on October 30, 2019, 03:17:01 PM
Talked to my snap on dealer today and this is what he said about the black tools ( not the impact)  They are not a military grade they are what they call industrial grade. Same exact as the chrome but they will rust and they are guaranteed. Just a little cheaper.
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: Brads70 on October 30, 2019, 03:34:49 PM
I have a few "specialty" tools from snap -on but most of my stuff is Mastercraft from Canadian Tire. I have some tools from Princess Auto ( like harbor freight in the USA) that are PRO-POINT brand , they seem good, had them for a few years now, warranty is good. I really like and use the gear wrenches quite a bit.
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: MoparLeo on October 30, 2019, 03:34:56 PM
 A large percentage of the cost of any tool sold on a tool truck is the cost of giving credit/payments for no interest to buyers who generally have poor to no credit. They live from paycheck to paycheck and move alot from place to place. Not all, but a lot of them do nationwide. The tool truck owners used to have a hard time tracking down guys that had accounts but now with the internet, cell phones and just new tech it is much easier to track people down. The tools if sold in a brick and mortar store would be much more reasonable. After the initial investment in tooling and other mfg. equipment the cost to produce the tool is very low, regardless of "quality". Made in Japan had a poor image after WW2 because they lacked resources/raw materials and relied on scrap to rebuild their country and economy. Just like Made in Japan no longer means low quality neither do most other major economies. At least made in Japan or made in China likely means that a Japanese or Chinese person is doing the manual labor part of the mfg. Made in USA , Who really knows who made it .?  :notsure:
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: torredcuda on October 31, 2019, 06:04:35 AM
Quote from: dodj on October 29, 2019, 06:31:33 AM
Quote from: Rich G. on October 29, 2019, 05:47:27 AM
I thought I heard the black was a military grade
I hear the term 'military grade' more and more. Anybody know what it really means?
Ford likes to say their truck is made from 'military grade' aluminium. What's that supposed to mean? It can take a few bullet hits?

I laugh every time I hear an ad that says that as there is really no such thing as "military grade", same for "aircraft aluminum", it`s just sales hype. What they are referring to is the product meets a certain military (MS) or aerospace (AS) specification for the material or coating process but those are widely used in commercial applications as well.
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: torredcuda on October 31, 2019, 06:12:37 AM
When I was doing bodywork for a living I bought mostly Snap-On, Blue Point and Mac with some Cornwell and Matco mixed in as well as some Craftsman I had, after years of use the Snap-On and Mac have held up the best but the others are close behind. My opinion now - Snap-On is worth the money for certain items, others are just fine and are less expensive for most other tools especially for home use, Harbor Freight and comparable is considered light use and throw away when it breaks stuff.
Title: Re: Instead of Snap-On tools
Post by: pbajeff on December 13, 2019, 07:14:06 AM
I went to school at Okmulgee, OK in 76 majoring in Diesel Mechanics. The school had a contract with Snap-On to furnish all the students tools. It was a 20 year contract that was signed in 1957 and the prices for the basic starter set were set in the contract. The starter set included 1/2" drive socket set, end wrenches, screwdrivers, and a few misc items. You would not believe the prices I could get those tools for at that time at the local pawn shops and the other kids that were quitting school or wanting some party money. I told all my family all I wanted for Christmas and birthdays was money. I would buy all I could money for at the time from the kids around school and the pawn shops then I would bring them home and trade out with the local Snap On dealer for other stuff I did not have. In the 40+ years since then I have added to my tool collection by picking up Snap On and Mac at swap meets or pawn shops here and there. I have also tried other brands occasionally but I always go back to those 2 brands. They just feel better to me. I have broken a few of them over the years and the warranty is only as good as your local dealer.
I have recently bought some Williams brand tools for the plant where I am manager and they seem to be holding up really well and the guys like them also.
All that said - for me personally I wont buy anything else any more.