thoughts on.....

[Christian]

these 2 cars please, i am new to the forum and to the "cuda", opinions on these 2 cars are much appreciated

https://www.flemingsultimategarage.com/vehicles/2860/1971-plymouth-cuda

https://www.flemingsultimategarage.com/vehicles/2819/1970-plymouth-cuda-aar

thanks

[bluespruce]

Welcome from Colorado

[anlauto]

Decent cars...dealership priced...

[Christian]

what are they worth in your opinion?

[cuda hunter]

That EV2 Looks to be on value.  Nice looking car. 
Sure doesn't give you much of a description as to the past history of the car.

Show quality restoration? 

[Cuda Cody]

Welcome @Christian    

Is there any photos of the underside of the 71 Cuda?

[Katfish]

Looks nice,

"Posi rearend AND show waxed....."

[cuda hunter]

That AAR is sweet. 
But not "restored".  I don't think.  That bottom is not supposed to be black. 

Pricing appears to be in line with other aar's.  But it might be a little high due to it being an auto. 
 
  What say you "guru's"..? 

[Christian]

i dig the AAR as well, like the 71 as well.  i have a 66 gto i am discussing a possible trade plus cash for one of them

[cuda hunter]

Just curious.  What color goat? 
I have a 67, gold. 

[Christian]

blue

[ledphoot]

If I were to choose I'd go with the AAR, they both look nice, but that AAR is a sweet looking car. The pricing is a little high, but it doesn't seem too crazy, I have seen cars like this sell from individuals locally for the same kind of money.  I'd inspect either one of them top to bottom and inside out before making a deal. I have been bit more than once by a perfumed pig so do your homework and know what you are truly getting.

EDIT: Your GOAT looks like a sweet ride! You sure you want to let that beauty go?

[CudaMoparRay]

They both look good to me depending on what model you like best. Just a little too much IMO  From Sylmar, CA

[anlauto]

Okay...The 1971 Cuda has tons of incorrect details, the biggest being the totally wrong seats and seat belts, manifolds, etc...Judging by the fender tag, all the cool options were added...NOT a rear spoiler car, NOT a billboard car.....

For these reasons I think the car is almost $20K over priced....


Now I feel the AAR is a better restored car, but has a fair share of incorrect details as well....biggest being the underside painted black, HOWEVER if you're looking for a driver, that doesn't really matter....It has the wrong console, but I like the correct tires....
It's a desirable colour, but the auto holds it back.

This is NOT an $80K AAR, but it is pretty close, maybe high $60's low $70's

Both these cars deserve a very close inspection, certainly for the asking prices....you would need to determine, documentation, matching numbers etc...etc...